Tom Morris

7 January 2010

A pungent mix of programming, philosophy, pedanticism, procrastination, perplexity, peripheral political polemic, and platters of preposterousness.

Carter Ruck threatens bloggers over ‘Maddie - the Truth of the Lie’

Gerry and Kate McCann, parents of the missing - presumed dead - Madeleine McCann, have employed the services of newspaper-threatening, superinjunction superstars Carter-Ruck (previously best known for helping to cover up Parliamentary proceedings) to threaten with a lawsuit any blogger who posts the text of Goncalo Amaral’s book which, in English, is titled “Maddie - the Truth of the Lie”. Amral is a former police detective who worked on the McCann case. While I take no interest in the truth or falsity of Mr. Amaral’s book, this shows yet another attempt by Carter-Ruck to suppress free expression using British libel law and injunctions.

Solicitors at Carter-Ruck must be quite familiar with the Streisand effect - the idea that attempts to supress otherwise uninteresting information make it immediately more interesting. Well, consider this one an own goal. I had heard precisely nothing about Mr Amaral’s book, but it took me less than five minutes to find a full PDF of the book in Portugese and in French translation, as well as a rough translation into English. Carter-Ruck made it particularly easy by including the URI of the website they were complaining about in the letter. Just saying. There’s also a video based on Amaral’s book which has been translated into English. You may be able to find it if you, err, have a look on a popular Internet video site owned by Google.

Really, well done Carter-Ruck. These threats are really helping your clients.

House of Lords Conservatives are trying to remove protection in the Equality Bill for “philosophical” beliefs and limit it to just religious beliefs. See this statement from the Conservative Humanists. This is very concerning to me as an atheist, a humanist, and as a compatibilist about free will, a realist about universals, a scientific realist, a Rawlsian, an evidentialist, a monist, a fan of various programming languages, a sceptic of various paranormal beliefs, a holder of a number of political, aesthetic and social opinions. I sure don’t want the nominalists or dualists discriminating against me.